The Giving Tree
(some parts from a report by S.Bruehler)
The Giving Tree, one of Shel Silverstein 's earliest works, has been one of his biggest sellers, and one of the most successful children's books in years. It's a story about a relationship of give and take between a boy and a tree through out both the tree's and the boy's life span. As a child the boy plays in the tree, eats the apples and sits in the shade. As an adolescent the boy rests here with his girlfriend. As a man he takes and uses the tree's freely given wood to build a house, later chopping down the tree to build a boat. When the man is old all the tree can give is a stump for the old man to rest upon. (Sely Friday)
Originally when The Giving Tree was presented to a publisher, it was rejected by editor William Cole who later commented: "I was working at Simon & Schuster in the early 1960's when he came in and showed me The Giving Tree. I told him that it was a nice book, but since it fell between two stools, children and adult, it would never sell." (Edwin McDowell, "Shel Silverstein." New York Times Book Review, November 8,1981 ). However, since that time, it has been published and has achieved much acclaim. The Giving Tree is a difficult book to categorise, it equally appeals to the sophisticated and the simple, the reverent and the irreverent.
Even though, The Giving Tree, is one of Silverstein's most successful books, it is not one of his favourites. He commented that "its just a relationship between two people; one gives, the other takes" (Richard R. Lingeman, "The Third Mr. Silverstein," New York Times Book Review, April 30, 197
. However, some suggest that the popularity of the book might just be because of this, the fact that it presents just one idea. Naturally, Silverstein is happy with the book's success, but he does not agree with this reason. He feels that children are able to deal with many ideas at one time: "A story could deal with more, even 50, and so can the reader, if the ideas are all laid out". (Jean F. Mercier. "Shel Silverstein," Publishers Weekly, February 24, 1975).