Great practice indeed Similarly to Buddha/bodhisavattas will rather not appearing conspicuously than allowing such narcissistical personality to develop non-benevolence karmic from their way of narcissism. Likewise to some great charitable personalities were also suffering this form of narcissism past and present. What a Namo Buddha Amitabha
so if someone is getting bullied by another - they should not take the view of a 'narcissist' and instead try to address he overall situation?
What if the person doing the bullying keeps on doing so?
My point/question is, it's fine if you can or are trying to apply this approach, but there are often others around you that don't. Is a person able to successfuly and repeatedly apply this approach without puting themselves in a disadvantaged situation?
Are you simply unhappy or angry with the person, the bully or are you held hostage by fear and feels isolated? If the first, then stand back a bit and take a breather. When composed, you may then take a position with a more positive outcome, if not for both, at least for yourself! If the second, you must break out your own isolation of fear. Most bullies hide behind a false sense of superiority, if physically, usually threatens the victim to silence. If in the internet, behind the veil of anonymity. I am sorry that I am unable to be more specific as there variability in bullying and its' victims. Often a bully as exposed as a coward, the bullying will stop. However, I prefer to empower the victim and hopefully not create another bully.
my post was just an example.
..but to continue with that example;
According to the approach, one shouldn't focus on oneself right? That's fine, so u try and do what u can to see the broader issues (e.g. the bully has deeper problems, that's perhaps why he/she is a bully etc etc), but in the meanwhile the vicim is still getting a punch in the head for no reason everytime they cross paths.
If the bully does so because they don't like the victim's face, whilt the victim keeps on 'stepping back and taking a breather', he/she is putting themselves in a disadvantaged situation by having to bear those hits day in day out.
I'm not disagreeing with your point. I'm just curious as to how straight fwd it actually is to implement in the world we exist in.
Or work in your father's/mother's company! Heh! Heh! Then no body will bully you!
Bullies thrive on getting a response from their victims.
a believer sees a mirror of a greater believer none other than himself is an attachment of a narcissist's belief
Originally posted by Weychin:... Train yourself mentally and physically.
.... One needs to be adapt socially or extremely competent in one’s own field in order not to be held hostage.
....but i thought it isn't supposed to be about "me"?
Me not trying to debate your point, just asking questions to clarify before justifying it to.......myself.
Originally posted by Loor:....but i thought it isn't supposed to be about "me"?
Me not trying to debate your point, just asking questions to clarify before justifying it to.......myself.
Originally posted by Weychin:Perhaps I've missed your point. Let's say we are having this discussion, somewhere along the way. I feel threatened, since I am narcissistic, it is all about me, my ego, so I go anal and I start getting personal.I start attacking you,( defending myself), even though it was never your intention in the first place. You get surprised as you did not anticipate this, you retaliate as you are now feeling threatened. The common thing is both of us got emotional because we both felt threatened! With empathy with regards to the other person, one will not get too emotional with the other person, we will have a higher threshold before we start feeling threatened. If possible, try to disarm the person's aggression with your charm! It is not possible if you are threatened and feel angry or afraid! This is about having emotional maturity! Most bullies need to work up an aggressive response before becoming intimidating. They subconsciously size you up by signs mixture of fear and anger. They get their fix by humiliating others. Physically,let's use martial arts as example, when engaging an opponent, one must never lose one's cool, either anger or fear, for it will cloud our judgement. In the end, the more conscious party will prevail. With an untensed body and mind one counters the opponent effortlessly! Think and play taichi!
right.
so in your first example....i agree - this is a situation where the approach is applicable, because it involves both parties eventually 'giving way', leading to a peaceful resolution.
In your second (bully) example however, it may not, as the bully doesn;t necessarily have anger towards you personally, but simply picks on u because of some past issues i.e. you're just the victim. The bully has no intentions to 'give in' because he can take out his issues/frustrations out on you. Taking up martial arts and defending yourself still requires some form of 'self preservation' doesn't it?
I think the approach is important and very enriching, but in the world we live in, very hard to apply in all circumstances.
thoughts?
Originally posted by Loor:right.
so in your first example....i agree - this is a situation where the approach is applicable, because it involves both parties eventually 'giving way', leading to a peaceful resolution.
In your second (bully) example however, it may not, as the bully doesn;t necessarily have anger towards you personally, but simply picks on u because of some past issues i.e. you're just the victim. The bully has no intentions to 'give in' because he can take out his issues/frustrations out on you. Taking up martial arts and defending yourself still requires some form of 'self preservation' doesn't it?
I think the approach is important and very enriching, but in the world we live in, very hard to apply in all circumstances.
thoughts?
With regards the response to bullying, it's not just the singular issue of self preservation at stake. It's also that the bully will continue with his/her ways if uncorrected. If the defense is not out of wanting to take revenge or a "you give me a black eye, I give you several broken ribs" sort of attitude, but simply a need to prevent oneself from getting hurt, then I would say a response is called for.
Nevertheless as people walking the spiritual path, I think it would be preferable where possible, to seek peaceful and "win-win" situations in matters involving conflict. If we behaved just like some gangster on the streets, then we need to ask ourselves if our personal cultivation has been effective.
Yep and that's what I'm gettin at - that in practical terms, sometimes a response is called for. If that means that you have to make a conscious decision to go and take up martial arts in order to defend yourself (not beat the bully to a pulp), then that still involves thinking about one's self and hence 'self preservation'....does it not?
To take the approach of 'impermanent' or 'we do not own these situations personally' is fine....but it may not be practical in the (non idealistic) world that we live in, unless you're willing to be consistently put in a disadvantaged situation.
Or am I seeing this in a too hostile kind of way...?
thanks.....though i still hold reservations on the issue, i think i am able to use parts of the concept to improve.
Cheers for sharing!