Transport Ministry and PTC wash their hands off public trans
-
Transport Ministry and PTC wash their hands off public transport subsidy for people with disability issue
Friday, 4 December 2009, 2:31 pm | 238 views
Ravi Philemon
I was the media spokesperson for CAN!’s campaign for transport subsidy for people with disability.CAN!’s petition signing and awareness raising campaign ended in May 2009. Since then, they have been trying to deliver the petition which was signed by 377 people. Both people who are able-bodied and people with disability.
They tried to deliver the petition through REACH after all they are supposed to be Reach everyone for Active Citizenry @ Home; and were to connect them to the relevant government agencies.
REACH however claimed that they did not receive the first email sent, asking them to connect CAN! with the Transport Ministry and then they replied to the second email, saying that they will try and make the second connection. Their subsequent email came about 2 weeks later (at the end of June 2009), asking CAN! to scan and send the petition to the Ministry of Transport.
But how can a poor, resource-less, informal group of people with disability like CAN!, scan a 25-page petition (with signatures) to the Transport Minister?
Then, the group got together and deliberated how else they could send the petition to the ministry. A few ideas were discussed. They even thought of meeting the Transport Minister through his Meet-the-People Session, but decided against it as they thought that it ‘would not be the right thing to do’.
Finally in September, they wrote another email direct to the transport minister. The reply came about 14 days later, not from the Transport Minister, but from some official from the ministry asking CAN! to submit the petition to the public transport operators.
CAN! got together again. “But why should we submit the petition to the public transport operators?” they wondered. “They are responsible to their shareholders and not to the people who elected them – even the people with disability”.
Finally, they decided to deliver an open petition to the Public Transport Council (PTC), copied to the Transport Ministry, and the public transport operators, through a press conference.
When the media tried to contact the PTC on this, they replied that they did not administer “any form of public transport subsidy”.
So, the transport ministry washes their hands-off from the issue, the PTC says they don’t know anything about it, which brings the people with disability back to being at the mercy of the public transport operators.
Which brings me back to the original question, “why should the public transport operators consider any request for subsidy from the members of the public (even disabled members of the public), when they are only responsible to their shareholders?”
Would the people with disability have to wait for 10 more years, for the public transport operators to explore if they should be given a subsidy or not?
-
Making people pay more for transport fares with no subsidy is to help the poor.
Just like GST.
Really.
-
Time to vote out PAP in 2010 general elections.
I am worried that PAP will instigate the elections during world cup so as to make use of the distraction to hoodwink people and trick people into voting for them.
-
can! should have gone to see the transport minister in his meet-the-people session. but of course be prepared to get the same taichi as the written reply. don't waste time with ptc. it's sole purpose of existence is to ok, (and only once, if i don't remember wrongly, not ok) fare hike for the public transport operators it is sad that gahmen agencies seem only interested in helping these monopolistic companies increase their profits and not in addressing their inadequacies.
-
Who is this stupid salesman?!
-
Since when does the gahmen care abt the disabled/elderly, the ruling elite only IMPOSES their strong view on pple ALL the TIME!
now with this silly undemocratic one day cooling period, it will get worse! -
This news had been featured to 'news 5 tonight' yesterday. To bus fans: the buses featured is SMB73A on 851 (most featured + interior shot and deploying ramp) plus many more OCs, bendies @ Yishun Int and only one hidden DM CAC O405 on 145. :S
-
I don't think it about being tai chi from pillar to post.
Most probably one of these two reasons.
1. Not knowing how to present a petition, and to whom.
2. No avenue for petitions.
-
During election time, bring it up to the relevant authorities.
Surely they will be extra mindful of the petition then.
-
As i mentioned
now is chirstmas season@!
they all busy spending money and buying
gifts
Where got time for ppl that need help..
-
Originally posted by noahnoah:
As i mentioned
now is chirstmas season@!
they all busy spending money and buying
gifts
Where got time for ppl that need help..
Maybe out of the country on holiday.
Cooking class overseas.
-
Originally posted by charlize:
Maybe out of the country on holiday.
Cooking class overseas.
yep lorall busy clearing annual leave liao
First Class SIA flight to 5 star hotel stay
-
CARRY ON
-
Typical blame pushing, greed is good, less profits = no good.
Typical failure of business conducting... oh well.... they don't care about their customers anyways....